Author of the Week / 16 November 2026

‘All Men Are Created Equal’? Poverty, Inequality and the American Dream in Sherman Alexie’s The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian

Author of the Week: Austria

Versopolis Academia


Introduction

This paper discusses how Sherman Alexie’s The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian presents the contradiction between the reality of Native American life and the ideal of the American Dream through the perspective of its Indigenous protagonist, Junior. The aim of this paper is to demonstrate how the statement in the Declaration of Independence – ‘We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness’ – contradicts the realities of poverty, discrimination and educational inequality experienced by Native Americans. This contradiction is portrayed in Sherman Alexie’s The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian and is also reflected in current data.

The idea for this topic emerged while reading the following passage from the novel: ‘But we reservation Indians don’t get to realize our dreams. We don’t get those chances. Or choices. We’re just poor. That’s all we are’ (Alexie 13). This passage raises the question of what the American Dream actually means for Indigenous Americans and whether they truly have the same opportunities as White Americans. According to Alexie’s novel, such equality of opportunity does not exist because, as Junior explains, reservation Indians are prevented from realising their dreams by the social and economic conditions in which they live.

According to the International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs, the Indigenous population of the United States is estimated to be between 3.1 and 8.7 million people (‘United States’). This significant figure suggests that many American citizens may still be affected by social and economic disadvantages. Therefore, this paper examines whether Alexie’s portrayal of poverty and inequality reflects the realities faced by Native Americans, with particular emphasis on educational opportunity and social inequality.

This paper argues that The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian challenges the ideal of equality by revealing how poverty, discrimination and unequal access to education prevent many Native Americans from enjoying the equality and opportunities promised in The Declaration of Independence. The following chapters will analyse how these social inequalities are represented in the novel and compare Alexie’s literary portrayal with current evidence on the socioeconomic situation of Native Americans.

1. ‘All Men Are Created Equal’: American Ideals and Native American Social Reality

To begin with, it is necessary to define the concept of the American Dream. According to the Cambridge Dictionary, the American Dream is the belief that everyone who lives in the United States has the same opportunity to become successful and happy, provided they work hard (‘American Dream’).

Adams, on the other hand, describes the American Dream in more detail as a dream ‘of a better, richer, and happier life for all our citizens of every rank,’ which he calls ‘the greatest contribution we have as yet made to the thought and welfare of the world’ (Adams 21). He also mentions that this kind of dream had to be present from the beginning and should be protected from forces that can become overwhelming for the inhabitants of the United States (Adams 21). In his definition, it can be argued that he highlights the idea of equality for every U.S. citizen, regardless of rank, origin, sex or skin colour. This includes Black people as well as Native Americans. In this definition, we can also see the possibility of achieving a financially better life, again independent of origin.

In contrast, The Declaration of Independence mentions only ‘men’ in its well-known sentence about the equality of all people living on American soil. Of course, it could be argued that ‘men’ in this phrase refers to humanity in general, according to the Library of Congress (‘All Men Are Created Equal’). However, Zinn states that the Revolution failed to attract enslaved people and Native Americans (Zinn).

Junior, in Alexie’s The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, also mentions that Native Americans were of little interest to the American colonists: ‘We Indians really should be better liars, considering how often we’ve been lied to’ (Alexie 10). Junior’s words imply that Native Americans were exploited and abused, and it could be supposed that they were promised a better and richer life but were ultimately lied to.

Furthermore, the idea of the Dream appears several times in Sherman Alexie’s The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, for instance in the following quotation: ‘Seriously, I know my mother and father had their dreams when they were kids. They dreamed about being something other than poor, but they never got the chance to be anything because nobody paid attention to their dreams’ (Alexie 11).

Alexie highlights the lack of opportunities to achieve the dreams that Junior’s parents used to have. This can be understood as a contradiction to the ideal of the American Dream, which promises equality for every single person, provided that they work hard. In Junior’s view, living as a Native American seems to preclude the possibility of achieving the same level of success as White Americans: ‘But we reservation Indians don’t get to realize our dreams. We don’t get those chances. Or choices. We’re just poor. That’s all we are’ (Alexie 13).

Moreover, Alexie describes a perception shared by many Native Americans in the following passage: ‘I know. I know, but some Indians think you have to act white to make your life better. Some Indians think you become white if you try to make your life better, if you become successful’ (Alexie 131). Therefore, the novel suggests that success is only possible for White people and that Native Americans have to adapt to White society or become assimilated, thereby risking the loss of their Native American identity, as happened under the assimilation practices of the federal Indian boarding school system, which operated from 1819 to 1969 and aimed to suppress Indigenous languages, religions and cultural practices (‘Department of the Interior Releases’). The novel continues this idea when Junior states: ‘And because you’re Indian you start believing you’re destined to be poor’ (Alexie 13). This assumption describes the vicious cycle of being Native American.

Alexie does, however, present one possible chance to get out of this vicious cycle: escaping from the reservation, that is, following the American Dream, as Junior’s sister does. Junior tells the reader: ‘But I just kept thinking that my sister’s spirit hadn’t been killed. She hadn’t given up. This reservation had tried to suffocate her, had kept her trapped in a basement, and now she was out roaming the huge grassy fields of Montana’ (Alexie 91).

Junior explains his sister’s plan to go away by saying: ‘She was trying to live out her dream. We should have all been delirious that she’d moved out of the basement’ (Alexie 91). He also tries to live his American Dream through drawing. Junior wants to improve his drawing skills because he sees drawing as the only way to have the same chances of success as a White American. He says: ‘So I draw because I feel like it might be my only real chance to escape the reservation’ and then adds: ‘That’s the only way I can become rich and famous’ (Alexie 6). This passage suggests that Junior sees artistic expression as a possible way to overcome the social limitations of reservation life and to participate in the promise of the American Dream.

On the other hand, the idea of the American Dream in Sherman Alexie’s The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian could also be closely connected to the concept of the melting pot, which serves as a metaphor for ethnic assimilation in American society (Nahshon). Zangwill writes:

Celt and Latin, Slav and Teuton, Greek and Syrian, – black and yellow VERA: Jew and Gentile – DAVID: Yes, East and West, and North and South, the palm and the pine, the pole and the equator, the crescent and the cross – how the great Alchemist melts and fuses them with his purging flame! Here shall they all unite to build the Republic of Man and the Kingdom of God. Ah, Vera, what is the glory of Rome and Jerusalem where all nations and races come to worship and look back, compared with the glory of America, where all races and nations come to labour and look forward! (Zangwill)

According to the concept of the melting pot, all nationalities should be blended equally into a single, cohesive culture (Hurd). However, Hurd further adds that ‘U.S. immigration policies reflected these assimilation pressures, often favouring those from Northern and Western Europe while restricting immigrants from other regions deemed less likely to fit into the melting pot’.

This very idea of not fitting into the American melting pot is highlighted by Junior when he says: ‘Well, of course, man. We Indians have LOST EVERYTHING. We lost our native land, we lost our languages, we lost our songs and dances. We lost each other. We only know how to lose and be lost’ (Alexie 173). He does not describe an equal blending into a new homogeneous American culture; rather, he mentions the loss of Native American identity. This loss of identity will be discussed further in this paper.

2. Poverty and Social Inequality among Native Americans

The description of poverty among Native Americans runs throughout the novel. Thus, Junior tells the reader: ‘And because you’re Indian you start believing you’re destined to be poor’ (Alexie 13).

It can be assumed that Junior also hopes for a transformative moment for Native American reservations because of his dream of being a magician. This dream is unrealistic; nevertheless, he wishes to become a magician and realise it. He writes: ‘I wish I were magical, but I am really just a poor-ass reservation kid living with his poor-ass family on the poor-ass Spokane Indian Reservation’ (Alexie 7). These quotations lead the reader to conclude that being Native American means being born into poverty and that this social status cannot be changed.

Indeed, Junior’s observations could also be connected to current statistical data provided by the American Community Survey, according to which, across the United States, ‘1 in 3 Native Americans is living in poverty, with a median income of $23,000 a year’ (‘What Drives Native American Poverty?’). This high percentage of poverty among Native Americans concerns sociologists. For example, Redbird states:

‘Poverty has been, for over a century, a huge part of the conversation about Indigenous well-being, but to a large extent we don’t even know what drives Native [American] poverty, what causes it, and where it comes from.’ She also mentions: ‘And without those answers, it’s awfully hard to know how we can fix it.’ (‘What Drives Native American Poverty?’)

However, Alexie mentions the consequences of being poor on Native American reservations, such as hunger and inferior health care. In this case, Junior explains to the reader what being poor means. He presents an equation: ‘Poverty = empty refrigerator + empty stomach’ (Alexie 8), and explains further: ‘And sure, sometimes, my family misses a meal, and sleep is the only thing we have for dinner, but I know that, sooner or later, my parents will come bursting through the door with a bucket of Kentucky Fried Chicken’ (Alexie 8). From this quotation, the reader can conclude that being hungry is common in the reservation life of Native Americans.

However, Alexie does not describe missing meals as the biggest problem of being poor. Instead, he mentions the inability to help somebody whom a poor Native American loves because of a lack of money. For example, Junior tells the reader about his best friend Oscar, an adopted stray mutt, when Junior wants to bring him to the vet:

And sure, Oscar was only an adopted stray mutt, but he was the only living thing that I could depend on. He was more dependable than my parents, grandmother, aunts, uncles, cousins, and big sister. He taught me more than any teachers ever did. Honestly, Oscar was a better person than any human I had ever known. (Alexie 9)

Hence, because of a lack of money, Junior loses his best friend, which he regards as a considerable loss.

Alexie does not explicitly give an answer to the question of the causes of Native American poverty. However, while reading Alexie’s novel The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, the reader could come to the conclusion that the relationship between Native Americans and ‘White’ Americans could be understood as a factor contributing to poverty among Native Americans. Alexie also highlights several times the lack of good job opportunities as well as educational opportunities for Native Americans. For instance, he describes Junior’s sister, Mary, as a motivated and engaged person who wants to integrate into ‘White society’ and, furthermore, find a job. She writes to Junior: ‘I love it here in Montana. …I’m still looking for a job...’ (Alexie 100). Mary writes again later: ‘I am still looking for a job. They keep telling me I don’t have enough experience. But how can I get enough experience if they don’t give me a chance to get experience?’ (Alexie 133). She feels humiliated and disappointed, but she does not give up.

Junior mentions earlier the lack of job opportunities as a Native American when he wants to find a way to help his best friend Oscar: ‘What kind of job can a reservation Indian boy get? I was too young to deal blackjack at the casino; there were only about fifteen green grass lawns on the reservation (and none of their owners outsourced the mowing jobs)’ (Alexie 10).

The persistent poverty on Native American reservations could also cause lower educational levels and consequently fewer job opportunities. According to the Native Hope blog, many Native American students have negative experiences at school:

Because of the impoverished economies of many reservations, many Native American children attend underfunded schools. This means their educational opportunities are insufficient – schools, programs, and teachers do not receive adequate funds. Even the federal government’s Impact Aid program, in place to serve underprivileged children, is far from adequate. (Native Hope)

According to data from the National Indian Education Association, ‘Over one-third (37%) of AI/AN[1] students and one-quarter (25%) of NHOPI students attend high-poverty public schools. That is compared to just 8% of white public-school students’ (National Indian Education Association). Junior mentions this aspect as well: ‘How often do you hear the words ‘Indian’ and ‘college’ in the same sentence? Especially in my family. Especially in my tribe’ (Alexie 180).

Alexie also mentions educational inequality on Native American reservations. Junior’s parents cannot afford to buy new, up-to-date schoolbooks, and Junior must use his mother’s books. He writes: ‘My school and my tribe are so poor and sad that we must study from the same dang books our parents studied from. That is absolutely the saddest thing in the world’ (Alexie 31). Books that are more than thirty years old cannot convey current knowledge, which pupils should receive in school. According to the Common Core State Standards, educational standards ‘were drafted by experts and teachers from across the country and are designed to ensure students are prepared for today’s entry-level careers, freshman-level college courses, and workforce training programs’ (‘What Parents Should Know’). A lack of access to modern schoolbooks prevents reservation pupils from acquiring the knowledge expected of them today. Perhaps this is the reason Junior tells the reader that studying with his parents’ books is the saddest thing in the world. This aspect also prevents Native American children from having the same opportunities for success as White American children who do not live on reservations and contradicts the ideal of the American Dream. As Junior says: ‘What do Indians have to be so thankful for?’ (Alexie 102).

3. ‘A Part-Time Indian’: Identity Between Reservation and White Society

It can be argued that, through the title of the novel and his portrayal of Junior’s life, Alexie highlights the identity struggles experienced by many Native Americans. This can also be seen from the statistical data that have already been mentioned in the previous chapter.

Being a ‘part-time Indian’ means being neither fully Indian nor fully White American. Junior reveals: ‘I realized that, sure, I was a Spokane Indian. I belonged to that tribe. But I also belonged to the tribe of American immigrants’ (Alexie 217). Thus, the protagonist is caught between two seemingly conflicting identities. While White identity seems to threaten his Indigenous identity, he also wants to preserve that identity. Junior explains: ‘Reservations were meant to be prisons. … We were supposed to disappear’ (Alexie 216).

Junior also says: ‘They call me an apple … red on the outside and white on the inside’ (Alexie 132). Alexie did not coin this expression. According to Obermoller, this idiom has a negative connotation and is used ‘as a slur among Native American communities to accuse another Indigenous person of not being Indigenous enough’ (Obermoller). The same comparison also appears in Eric Gansworth’s Apple: Skin to the Core, first published in 2020, which suggests that the expression is widely used.

However, from this quotation it can be concluded that not only does Junior himself believe that he is both Native American and White American, but those around him also see him in this way. In contrast, the people around Junior do not really want to acknowledge his White identity. Junior says: ‘And no matter how good I was, I would always be an Indian. And some folks just found it difficult to compare an Indian to a white guy’ (Alexie 181). This quotation can be interpreted as an implicit appeal against discrimination. According to statistical data from Health Services Research,

Discrimination and harassment are widely reported by Native Americans across multiple domains of their lives, regardless of geographic or neighborhood context. Native Americans report major disparities compared to whites in fair treatment by institutions, particularly with health care and police/courts. Results suggest modern forms of discrimination and harassment against Native Americans are systemic and untreated problems. (Findling et al.)

Conclusion

This paper has shown that Sherman Alexie’s The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian questions the American ideal that ‘all men are created equal’ by presenting poverty, social inequality, educational disadvantage and identity conflict as central aspects of Junior’s life and the lives of his relatives.

While the idea of the American Dream suggests that every person in the United States can achieve success and happiness through hard work, Junior’s experiences reveal that this promise is limited by social and historical conditions. The novel presents poverty as a structural condition of Native American reservations that affects food, health care, education, job opportunities and future prospects. Junior’s poverty can therefore be seen as a symbol of the wider inequality faced by many Native Americans in the present day.

Junior’s identity as a ‘part-time Indian’ shows that the pursuit of success is connected to cultural conflict. His pursuit of better opportunities also creates the impression that he belongs neither fully to the reservation nor fully to White American society.

It can be argued that Alexie’s novel does not reject the American Dream completely but shows that this dream is unequally accessible. For Junior, hope is possible, but it requires leaving the reservation and struggling with poverty, discrimination and cultural loss. In this way, The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian exposes the gap between the promise of equality and the lived reality of Indigenous Americans, showing that the American Dream exists as an ideal, but is not equally attainable for Native Americans.

Works Cited and Consulted

Primary Material

Alexie, Sherman. The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian. Andersen Press, 2015.

Secondary Materials

Adams, James Truslow. The Epic of America. 1931. Introduction by Howard Schneiderman, Routledge, 2017.

‘All Men Are Created Equal.’ Creating the United States, Library of Congress, www.loc.gov/exhibits/creating-the-united-states/interactives/declaration-of-independence/equal/index.html. Accessed 12 July 2026.

‘American Dream.’ Cambridge Dictionary, Cambridge University Press, dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/american-dream. Accessed 12 July 2026.

‘Apple (Skin to the Core).’ Publishers Weekly, 23 September. 2020, www.publishersweekly.com/9781646140138. Accessed 12 July 2026.

Davis, Julie. ‘American Indian Boarding School Experiences: Recent Studies from Native Perspectives.’ OAH Magazine of History, vol. 15, no. 2, Winter 2001, pp. 20–22. JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/25163421.

‘The Declaration of Independence: A Transcription.’ National Archives, 25 February. 2026, www.archives.gov/founding-docs/declaration-transcript. Accessed 12 July 2026.

‘Department of the Interior Releases Investigative Report, Outlines Next Steps in Federal Indian Boarding School Initiative.’ U.S. Department of the Interior, 11 May 2022, www.doi.gov/pressreleases/department-interior-releases-investigative-report-outlines-next-steps-federal-indian. Accessed 12 July 2026.

Findling, Mary G., et al. ‘Discrimination in the United States: Experiences of Native Americans.’ Health Services Research, vol. 54, suppl. 2, December 2019, pp. 1431–1441. Wiley Online Library, https://doi.org/10.1111/1475-6773.13224.

Gansworth, Eric. Apple: Skin to the Core. Levine Querido, 2020.

Hurd, Mary G. ‘Melting Pot Theory.’ EBSCO Research Starters, 2018, www.ebsco.com/research-starters/sociology/melting-pot-theory. Accessed 12 July 2026.

‘It All Starts with Education.’ Native Hope, blog.nativehope.org/it_all_starts_with_education. Accessed 12 July 2026.

Nahshon, Edna. From the Ghetto to the Melting Pot: Israel Zangwill’s Jewish Plays. Wayne State UP, 2006.

National Indian Education Association. ‘Data on Native Students.’ National Indian Education Association, www.niea.org/native-student-data. Accessed 12 July 2026.

Native Hope. ‘The Issues Surrounding Native American Education.’ Native Hope, 16 September 2024, blog.nativehope.org/the-issues-surrounding-native-american-education. Accessed 12 July 2026.

Obermoller, Sabine. ‘Gansworth Brings ‘Apple: Skin to the Core’ Discussion to CLSC.’ The Chautauquan Daily, 1 August 2024, chqdaily.com/2024/08/gansworth-brings-apple-skin-to-the-core-discussion-to-clsc/. Accessed 12 July 2026.

‘The Indigenous World 2024: United States of America.’ International Work Group for Indigenous Affairs, 24 March 2024, www.iwgia.org/en/publications/iw-2024-united-states. Accessed 12 July 2026.

‘What Drives Native American Poverty?’ Institute for Policy Research, Northwestern University, 24 February 2020, www.ipr.northwestern.edu/news/2020/redbird-what-drives-native-american-poverty.html. Accessed 12 July 2026.

‘What Parents Should Know.’ Common Core State Standards Initiative, thecorestandards.org/what-parents-should-know/. Accessed 12 July 2026.

Zangwill, Israel. The Melting-Pot. Project Gutenberg, 18 December 2007, www.gutenberg.org/files/23893/23893-h/23893-h.htm. Accessed 12 July 2026.

Zinn, Howard. A People’s History of the United States. HarperCollins, 2015.


ChatGPT was used in the writing of this paper to improve linguistic formulation and style and to check spelling as well as MLA citation style. The author bears responsibility for the content.


[1] AI/AN refers to American Indian and Alaska Native.

Author

Maria Schattleitner

Maria Schattleitner studied German Studies at Jagiellonian University in Kraków. She is currently pursuing a teacher education degree at the University College of Teacher Education Styria, specialising in English, Russian and German as a Second Language and Language Education. Her academic interests lie primarily in interdisciplinary research and at the intersections of linguistics, literary studies and cultural studies.

Related