Opinion/ 21 March 2018
In his book, Petits traités 1, Pascal Quignard subtitled the 7th treatise: ‘On the relationships that text and image do not maintain’. He says in particular:
‘There is no link between text and image, other than the image of the text itself. Writing - like any mode of expression - seeks the un-transposable, and the signs are there, by function, to make up for the object that they have ceased to show and that has disappeared. The proper character of written signs is not to show what they designate; they mean; they reign in what can’t be shown’. And further on:
‘The image cuts the grass under the foot of language. To show the written word as a spectacle: If it appears, it is annihilated; it begins to be visible; it ceases to be readable’.
When one is a little familiar with his work, one understands that it is a provocation, a stone of impotence thrown in front of the complexity of the subject addressed. Indeed, the links between words and images cannot be reduced to the question of signifier and significant, and Quignard, in his hybrid fiction work, has explored the other springs of these links several times. If they are intimately linked to the media that support them, these links follow the evolution of writing through the centuries. From the illumination to the comic strip to the photo novel, the interweaving of meanings carried by the combination of images and words has recently been extended in new directions, outside books, and with force by social networks, and their very architecture.
Unfortunately, Pascal Quignard can’t shed any light on this point, as he explains on his website: ‘The writer Pascal Quignard has no account on any social network whatsoever. Any social account of the @PascalQuignard type is a usurped account’.
We will, therefore, have to conduct our own investigation. Especially since this communicative tool - which I would dare call “language” - seems to be the blind spot of these depreciated social media, among other things, because they would push people to write short, to write badly, to prefer images, less complex and faster to apprehend. If these assertions are true, it seems to me that they do not do justice to what is otherwise developing as new potentialities there.
In the context of this essay, I will discuss two approaches, which seem to me exemplary because they carry with them a perversion of the codes accepted in social networks and therefore a political dimension.
As she explains it very well in the short text that begins this series: ‘By making the selfie, both the objectifier and the object are assembled in one composition. Myself, as the object, standing in front of the catcallers represents the reversed power ratio which is caused by the project’.
The process works in two stages, each of which amplifies the violence expressed and felt. First of all, it is true that the square photograph captures the voyeur and the object of his harassment in the same space, annihilating the voyeur’s impunity. But what, in my opinion, makes the proposal perfect - and what the presentation text omits - is the juxtaposition of the image and the text that is supposed to precede it. This word, which, coupled with a seemingly harmless portrait, denounces the trivialization of this social trend.
In another vein, but always with a desire to question the instrumentalization of bodies, James Fridman regularly publishes photographic diptychs on his Twitter account.
You will tell me: This has nothing to do with the evocative power of the literature Quignard is talking about! Not so sure! At a time when reality - through these same social networks - is over-documented, saturated, the capacity of literature to digest the mass of data made public every day is more than ever necessary to help us understand the society in which we live. Still, it is necessary that the craftsmen of literature sometimes accept to get rid of the prestige constituted by books and that they plunge where wild words and images abound.
One of Europe's leading philosophers and co-founder of DiEM25 on Covid-19-related infodemic, living in “the Mediterranean as in once was”, the climate and ecological apocalypse and much more
One of Europe's leading philosophers and co-founder of DiEM25 on Covid-19-related infodemic, living in “the Mediterranean as in once was”, the climate and ecological apocalypse and much more
Georges Simenon was Obsessed with Life (and Ladies)
A review of Michel Houellebecq's Sérotonine
On how the great silent movie came to life
On how the great silent movie came to life
The Jordan Peterson phenomenon (part 2)
The Jordan Peterson phenomenon (part 2)
Timur Vermes’ Look Who's Back
As state-owned TV channels gradually succumbed to the dumbness of private channels, traditional parties succumbed to the rhetoric of the right wing.
As state-owned TV channels gradually succumbed to the dumbness of private channels, traditional parties succumbed to the rhetoric of the right wing.
Review of Roberto Saviano's Zero Zero Zero
Not everything dictionaries or encyclopedias tell us or teach us is true. On the contrary, some entries are made by witty people.
Not everything dictionaries or encyclopedias tell us or teach us is true. On the contrary, some entries are made by witty people.
13 reasons
A Review of Aaron James’ Assholes: A Theory of Donald Trump
A Review of Aaron James’ Assholes: A Theory of Donald Trump
Tolerating the intolerant
One of Europe's leading philosophers and co-founder of DiEM25 on Covid-19-related infodemic, living in “the Mediterranean as in once was”, the climate and ecological apocalypse and much more
One of Europe's leading philosophers and co-founder of DiEM25 on Covid-19-related infodemic, living in “the Mediterranean as in once was”, the climate and ecological apocalypse and much more
Jordan Peterson (Part 1)
On censorhip in Egypt
No Wi-Fi in the hotel room? SACRILEGE!
The death of Carlo Giuliani
The death of Carlo Giuliani
Changing the meaning of the most important word
Changing the meaning of the most important word
Why is a communist salute in Italy more benign than a fascist?
Why is a communist salute in Italy more benign than a fascist?
Being replaced in capitalism
Fascist planned city of Sabaudia
It's very touching to read a poem about a dead sparrow. But then there is all this poo pets produce
It's very touching to read a poem about a dead sparrow. But then there is all this poo pets produce
Everybody has some guilty pleasures. Liberal cable TV, for instance. Because it actually instils hope after the rise of Donny T
Everybody has some guilty pleasures. Liberal cable TV, for instance. Because it actually instils hope after the rise of Donny T
Ethics and Politics
Why we need football
Forgiving Bryan Ferry and Other Artists
A Review of Green Book
The Shame of Living in Hungary, an Authoritarian Democracy
The Shame of Living in Hungary, an Authoritarian Democracy
On being the Other
Malta or How to find one's place in the world among a ton of historical burden, overfactitious contentment and lingering self-doubt.
Malta or How to find one's place in the world among a ton of historical burden, overfactitious contentment and lingering self-doubt.
How is contemporary politics influencing art practices?
How is contemporary politics influencing art practices?
Europe's movement to make neoliberalism its guiding economic doctrine was like a shiny express train
Europe's movement to make neoliberalism its guiding economic doctrine was like a shiny express train
And what the hell is Donaldistics?
On how to raise wise and realistic citizens. But not.
On how to raise wise and realistic citizens. But not.
An Introduction to the Social Media Stupidity
